How Restrictive Can Restrictive Covenants Be?

By Claudia Pollak, Esq., Updated October 19, 2020

Restrictive covenants are contractual agreements. Usually, an employer includes restrictive covenants in an employment agreement seeking to restrict a departing employee in some way. Examples of restrictive covenants include non-compete, non-solicitation, and confidentiality agreements.

Non-compete agreements typically feature a geographic limitation (do not open a competing business within 25 miles) or a time frame (do not work for a competitor until one year has passed). Courts have enforced non-compete agreements when they were necessary to protect an employer’s trade secrets or confidential customer information. As with any restrictive covenant, examining a non-compete provision is very case-specific and enforceability will depend upon the particular circumstances.

Non-solicitation agreements restrict an employee from soliciting business from his or her former employer’s customers. A non-poaching covenant seeks to prevent the departing employee from soliciting other employees to also leave the company.

Confidentiality provisions usually define types of information that a former employee cannot possess or use, such as customer lists, sales data, marketing materials, and other business plans. These provisions typically do not expire.

Restrictive covenants are generally disfavored by New York courts, but they can be viewed less critically when an employee agrees to a restrictive covenant in exchange for post-employment benefits such as a severance package. If an employer breaches the employment agreement, however, courts may not enforce any restrictive covenant contained in the agreement.

Courts can review restrictive covenants to determine whether the restrictions imposed are fair and enforceable. Factors to be considered include whether the restraint protects a legitimate interest of the employer, whether the restraint imposes an undue hardship on the employee and whether the restraint is harmful to the public. Courts can modify the restrictive covenant (“blue pencil” it is sometimes called) or reject it entirely. The more narrowly drafted a restrictive covenant is, the more likely it is to be considered enforceable.

Employers doing business in more than one state often include a choice-of-law provision in their contracts. Sometimes, however, a New York court might reject another state’s restrictive covenant law as contrary to New York’s public policy.

By |2020-10-19T22:48:54+00:00March 27, 2015|Business Law|
westchester county employment lawyer

Claudia Pollak

Claudia Pollak, Esq. is an experienced Westchester and NYC-based employment lawyer representing employees facing discrimination, retaliation or wrongful termination because of their race, disability, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender, or other protected characteristic. She also advises on executive severance agreements and restrictive covenants. Call her at 914-LAW-9111 (914-529-9111) for a free consultation.

Employment Discrimination

Employment Discrimination

Employees in Westchester County and other parts of New York state are protected from discrimination in employment based on a number of personal characteristics.

Learn More

Sexual Harassment

Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment at the workplace has always existed, but the #metoo movement has brought this ugly secret out into the glaring light of day.

Learn More

Disability Discrimination

Disability Discrimination

Being disabled can impact individuals in several important ways. For a great many Americans, however, it does not prevent them from working.

Learn More

Family Medical Leave Act

Family Medical Leave Act

Many employees in the state of New York are eligible for paid leave under New York’s short-term disability law and paid family leave law.

Learn More

Gender Discrimination

Gender Discrimination

There are many types of gender discrimination occurring in the workplace, including discrimination based on sexual orientation, pregnancy, or transgender or non-binary status.

Learn More

Hostile Work Environment

Hostile Work Environment

Some of our most vulnerable populations are experiencing increasingly stressful employment situations. In fact, many workers in America (up to 1 in 5) feel they work in a hostile or abusive work environment.

Learn More

Racial Discrimination

Racial Discrimination

While many businesses have openly acknowledged the problems of discrimination and inequity facing black workers in America as a result of the Black Lives Matter movement, racial discrimination still regularly occurs in the workplace.

Learn More

Severance Agreements

Severance Agreements

Whether your position is being eliminated in corporate downsizing, or you are getting laid off or fired for another reason, at some point in your life you may find yourself reviewing a severance agreement.

Learn More

Pregnancy Discrimination

Pregnancy Discrimination

The last thing you need when you’re starting a family – or growing one – is financial uncertainty or the stress and anxiety that comes from becoming the target of discriminatory treatment at work because of your pregnancy.

Learn More

New York Equal Pay Law

New York Equal Pay Law

New York Labor Law §194, requires that employees of a particular establishment be paid a wage that is equivalent to the wages paid to employees of the opposite sex, or of a different race or sexual orientation, or who are members of any other class of employees.

Learn More

GLOWING CLIENT REVIEWS

I consider myself fortunate to have been introduced to Claudia, who performed flawlessly on my behalf in extremely difficult and trying conditions. As a senior level executive, my expectations for professionalism and service delivery are high and I can honestly say that Claudia went far above and beyond my expectations to represent my best interests. She is tenacious and fights for her clients rather than pursuing the path of least resistance. Her case preparation was extremely thorough and diligent. When combined with her experience and high level of competence in employment law, she is a formidable adversary to any employer, large or small, who exercises digressions in employment tactics. It is without reservation that I recommend Claudia’s services to handle any employment matter, large or small, that requires legal finesse.

Richard Hayes

She puts the needs of her clients first.

Amanda Moody

Claudia knows the law and she explained to me every step of the way what she was doing and why… I slept very well at night knowing that she was on my side.

Steven Katz

Very knowledgeable lawyer…

Thomas Sauer

Smart, knowledgeable and accessible.

Gregory Fennell

TESTIMONIALS

Smart, knowledgeable and accessible. Claudia has expertly represented me since 2014 with several successful contracts negotiations.
Very knowledgable lawyer, very commendable.
She puts the needs of her clients first.
I wish I could give her a million stars.

LATEST NEWS & EVENTS

Contact Claudia for a Free Consultation!

Please contact us online for a free consultation.
Book a Free Consultation
Go to Top